| Platinum | Fratelli Molinaro |
| Gold | Four Corners Bakery |
| Silver | Raffaele's Cantina |
| Bronze | Bolton Pizza Panini |
| Top Pick | Allegro Fine Foods |
| Top Pick | Antica Osteria Italian Eatery Limited |
| Top Pick | Bluebird Cafe & Grill |
| Top Pick | Calabria Pizza Panini |
| Top Pick | Casamici Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Dolce Family Ristorante |